With the publication of the Milburn Review, outlining what Alan Milburn believes Andy Burnham's Labour government should do about welfare recipients aged 18-24, and what they would do to address the situation of NEETs - the unemployed who are Not in Education, Employment, or Training, there's a lot of media discourse about why this demographic exists, and why there are "so many" of them, as well as the inevitable "It'll never work" in regards to Milburn's recommendations - but not a lot of organisations talking about what they would do to address the situation of NEETs, of all ages.
At The Productive Pessimist, our lead consultant, Ash, brings lived experience of both being a welfare claimant who got caught up in a previous government's attempt to "solve the NEETs crisis" in 2010, and of working as an Employability Coach within an organisation subcontracted to provide the "specialised, tailored, localised support" that is yet again being announced as a radical improvement to the way NEETs are currently dealt with. (Spoiler alert: the support that organisation provided was local, but it was neither tailored nor specialised. It probably won't be this time, either, because government procurement hasn't been expanded in any meaningful way in the past 16 years, meaning that it'll be the 'usual suspects' of companies who don't otherwise do much of anything who'll get these subcontracts again...), giving us the ability to offer a person-centred, reality-grounded response to "What should we do about the problem of welfare dependency?"
The Productive Pessimist's way of working is to identify the one problem that encapsulates "all the problems" that individuals, teams, organisations, and countries spend significant resources seeking to address, and create a workable, affordable route to solve that one problem.
NEETs have been presented as a multi-faceted problem within the problem-strewn concept that is the welfare state, which is why Alan Milburn feels comfortable committing billions of pounds across at least 10yrs (which isn't achievable in any case - because that covers at least two different governments, and, since the UK Parliament rarely agrees to unanimously support a proposal, and, even if they did in the case of welfare form, they would be unable to guarantee the continuation of that proposal, since a central tenet of UK Parliamentary law is the "no one Parliament can bind another" - meaning future Parliaments are free to disregard any changes to the process and protocol brought in by their predecessors.
In fact, the one problem, both in regards to NEETs and the wider welfare state, is attitudes. The solution is a change of attitude - something which also happens to be lower cost than the proposals in the Milburn Review, and doesn't include driving young people into poverty because people without any medical background whatsoever prefer to disbelieve the realities of cherry-picked disabilities and health challenges.
. The media's attitude that every welfare recipient is a scrounger, who is getting more than someone working full-time: Just today (Wednesday 18th November), the Independent published an article claiming that "London families on benefits could potentially net £3,300 a month in various benefits, including housing benefit and PIP - more than a working family would take home from a full time job on the minimum wage, when that family has to pay their full housing costs, council tax, travel costs, and childcare!"
This is an example of the lazy attitude that has the media believing they can just say whatever they like about welfare recipients, without even doing the bare minimum of fact checking.
In reality, a working couple with (for the sake of argument) two children, where both parents made the national minimum wage would, after tax and National Insurance, take home £3,739 a month, including both their pay and the Child Benefit they would be entitled to - which, obviously, is more than the £3,300 a month cited by the Independent in a way which enables an (erroneous) interpretation that every welfare recipient is getting £3,300 a month, when the average welfare recipient gets only a little more than ten percent of that amount.
The working couple in this scenario could avoid childcare costs by one parent working a day shift, and the other a night shift (which, for many families in the 1990s, was a very common way of managing the demands of work and children), both could work from home, alternating responding to their childrens' needs, they may be able to avoid childcare costs altogether if they have family who are able to provide this for them without making a financial charge for the service. Undoubtedly, childcare is a considerable cost, but it is something that can be worked around, and, in any case, is almost always a discretionary luxury, since people generally make a choice about having children, and when they have them.
They would also be able to apply for PIP if either of them have disabilities, as PIP is assessed, but not means-tested, meaning it is entirely possible to be in full time employment and also receive PIP. If they were to apply for PIP, they would likely rapidly discover that the British media have significantly misrepresented the reality of PIP - the application process is complex, it requires a lot of deeply personal information, it is very adversarial in nature, and instances of assessors misrepresenting - or outright making up - what claimants have told them are shockingly common. As an idea of how disingenuous the media's insistence that "people are just being handed hundreds of pounds a month in PIP, without having to provide any proof that they even have disabilities!" - Ash, our lead consultant, is legally blind, and also diagnosed schizophrenic, while Morgana, our neurodiversity consultant and life coach, has cerebral palsy, compromised lung function, is partially sighted, and also diagnosed autistic; both Ash and Morgana have been refused PIP on three separate occasions. And the reason that "people don't even have to provide proof they have disabilities!", which arises from "people aren't even having to submit medical evidence" is because PIP assessors refuse to read medical evidence, and specifically request that it isn't sent alongside an application.
A simple way to begin the change of attitude in the media - and thus the communication of it to society in general - is to change the language used, from "benefit claimants" to "welfare recipients." The latter term more accurately represents the intention - and real-world manifestation - of how the payments involved work; enabling people to remain just about healthy enough to avoid becoming an unplanned cost to the NHS, have the means to make approaches for work, and to make discretionary purchases, which return income to the Exchequer via VAT receipts, and, more indirectly, taxes on profits from retail businesses.
. Society's attitudes, inherited from the media's attitude - as the government are already considering various schemes to "volun-tell" people into "community-based national service", a straightforward way to adjust society's attitudes to welfare recipients would be for all UK businesses to commit every employee to 100hrs per year of voluntary service within organisations specifically supporting disabled people, young people in care, kinship carers, asylum seekers, and the homeless. (Calm down, folks...100hrs a year is less than 2hrs a week per person...it almost certainly won't detract from business as usual, or reduce your productivity...) This would provide a holistic understanding of the realities facing these demographics, who most frequently fall foul of societal assumptions and misconceptions about the realities of their lives, and, particularly, the amount of financial assistance they receive from the State. It would also enable people who believe themselves "successful" and "financially secure" to realise how close to the experiences of these people they actually are.
. The attitude of Jobcentre Plus, DWP, and the wider government, to welfare recipients - this change would be most readily accomplished by prioritising recruitment to roles within Jobcentre Plus and the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to individuals who are currently in receipt of welfare support, particularly those who are disabled and/or long-term unemployed. This not only radically shifts the attitudes encountered within these organisations, but also actually meaningfully addresses the cost aspect of welfare dependency - if welfare recipients are prioritised for recruitment to roles in Jobcentre Plus and DWP, they are then removed from welfare dependency, and benefit instead from the earned income of relatively stable, long-term jobs. (Which seems a better bet than the six-month "taxpayer funded" jobs Milburn has suggested - which have already brought cries from businesses that they will "need" to be relieved of National Insurance costs if they take on 18-24yr old NEETs...)
. The attitude of employers to welfare recipients, particularly the disabled - this is a change which would also begin to be brought about through the required volunteering commitments discussed in changing social attitudes.
This is an example of the lazy attitude that has the media believing they can just say whatever they like about welfare recipients, without even doing the bare minimum of fact checking.
In reality, a working couple with (for the sake of argument) two children, where both parents made the national minimum wage would, after tax and National Insurance, take home £3,739 a month, including both their pay and the Child Benefit they would be entitled to - which, obviously, is more than the £3,300 a month cited by the Independent in a way which enables an (erroneous) interpretation that every welfare recipient is getting £3,300 a month, when the average welfare recipient gets only a little more than ten percent of that amount.
The working couple in this scenario could avoid childcare costs by one parent working a day shift, and the other a night shift (which, for many families in the 1990s, was a very common way of managing the demands of work and children), both could work from home, alternating responding to their childrens' needs, they may be able to avoid childcare costs altogether if they have family who are able to provide this for them without making a financial charge for the service. Undoubtedly, childcare is a considerable cost, but it is something that can be worked around, and, in any case, is almost always a discretionary luxury, since people generally make a choice about having children, and when they have them.
They would also be able to apply for PIP if either of them have disabilities, as PIP is assessed, but not means-tested, meaning it is entirely possible to be in full time employment and also receive PIP. If they were to apply for PIP, they would likely rapidly discover that the British media have significantly misrepresented the reality of PIP - the application process is complex, it requires a lot of deeply personal information, it is very adversarial in nature, and instances of assessors misrepresenting - or outright making up - what claimants have told them are shockingly common. As an idea of how disingenuous the media's insistence that "people are just being handed hundreds of pounds a month in PIP, without having to provide any proof that they even have disabilities!" - Ash, our lead consultant, is legally blind, and also diagnosed schizophrenic, while Morgana, our neurodiversity consultant and life coach, has cerebral palsy, compromised lung function, is partially sighted, and also diagnosed autistic; both Ash and Morgana have been refused PIP on three separate occasions. And the reason that "people don't even have to provide proof they have disabilities!", which arises from "people aren't even having to submit medical evidence" is because PIP assessors refuse to read medical evidence, and specifically request that it isn't sent alongside an application.
A simple way to begin the change of attitude in the media - and thus the communication of it to society in general - is to change the language used, from "benefit claimants" to "welfare recipients." The latter term more accurately represents the intention - and real-world manifestation - of how the payments involved work; enabling people to remain just about healthy enough to avoid becoming an unplanned cost to the NHS, have the means to make approaches for work, and to make discretionary purchases, which return income to the Exchequer via VAT receipts, and, more indirectly, taxes on profits from retail businesses.
. Society's attitudes, inherited from the media's attitude - as the government are already considering various schemes to "volun-tell" people into "community-based national service", a straightforward way to adjust society's attitudes to welfare recipients would be for all UK businesses to commit every employee to 100hrs per year of voluntary service within organisations specifically supporting disabled people, young people in care, kinship carers, asylum seekers, and the homeless. (Calm down, folks...100hrs a year is less than 2hrs a week per person...it almost certainly won't detract from business as usual, or reduce your productivity...) This would provide a holistic understanding of the realities facing these demographics, who most frequently fall foul of societal assumptions and misconceptions about the realities of their lives, and, particularly, the amount of financial assistance they receive from the State. It would also enable people who believe themselves "successful" and "financially secure" to realise how close to the experiences of these people they actually are.
. The attitude of Jobcentre Plus, DWP, and the wider government, to welfare recipients - this change would be most readily accomplished by prioritising recruitment to roles within Jobcentre Plus and the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to individuals who are currently in receipt of welfare support, particularly those who are disabled and/or long-term unemployed. This not only radically shifts the attitudes encountered within these organisations, but also actually meaningfully addresses the cost aspect of welfare dependency - if welfare recipients are prioritised for recruitment to roles in Jobcentre Plus and DWP, they are then removed from welfare dependency, and benefit instead from the earned income of relatively stable, long-term jobs. (Which seems a better bet than the six-month "taxpayer funded" jobs Milburn has suggested - which have already brought cries from businesses that they will "need" to be relieved of National Insurance costs if they take on 18-24yr old NEETs...)
. The attitude of employers to welfare recipients, particularly the disabled - this is a change which would also begin to be brought about through the required volunteering commitments discussed in changing social attitudes.
Additionally, if Jobcentre Plus and DWP were to create an unpaid cohort of mentors from among recently retired business leaders and entrepreneurs, who would work directly with welfare recipients, attitude adjustment among employers would be amplified, and their effects more rapidly felt.
Within Jobcentre Plus' current working practices, removing the limitation on funding formal education and professional development courses that means welfare recipients with qualifications at or above A-Level are deemed "too qualified" to be supported through Jobcentre Plus funding these courses and qualifications, even when these are required for someone to even be considered for jobs - for example, qualifying to Level 7 in HR, which is increasingly considered the "basic" requirement for HR roles, typically costs from £8,000-£10,000 in total; not a sum that the typical welfare recipient has access to (especially when you consider that claimants aren't allowed to have more than £6,000 in savings...), yet roles in HR are often more accessible than other career options for people with disabilities and health challenges, and also tend to provide greater job security - meaning that it would benefit the Exchequer if any welfare recipients who wanted to pursue opportunities within HR had their HR qualification fully funded, regardless of prior academic qualifications; ideally, this would be a 50/50 shared funding between Jobcentre Plus and an employer (who would obviously benefit from the labour of the individual once they were qualified); bringing an employer on-board before an individual was qualified would lower the risk that the welfare system would simply have another highly qualified person dependent on welfare, as well as enabling the individual to benefit from practical skills, and the employer to benefit from a new recruit who knows how their business, specifically, functions.
The Jobcentre associating more closely with business experts, and Jobcentre staff being comfortable allowing those experts to very much take the lead on the kinds of interventions that would be most relevant to employability.
The Jobcentre associating more closely with business experts, and Jobcentre staff being comfortable allowing those experts to very much take the lead on the kinds of interventions that would be most relevant to employability.

Comments
Post a Comment